What is a Section 278 Agreement?

A Section 278 Agreement is a legal agreement between a developer and a highway authority to carry out highway works.

How Safe Is A Home Birth? | Wollens Solicitors Devon

Home births are becoming increasingly popular across the UK, with many families seeking a more personalised and natural birthing experience. But with this rise in interest comes a vital question: how safe is it to give birth at home? The answer is nuanced, shaped by individual health factors, the quality of care available, and the support systems in place.

This is unfortunately a question which I can give a personalised answer to, as I elected to have a home birth with my first child, which subsequently ended up with an emergency transfer to hospital due to the midwife failing to refer me due to lack of progression in labour. Thankfully, my son was delivered safely, but the delivery was traumatic, both physically and psychologically.

What the Evidence Shows

Extensive research supports the safety of planned home births for low-risk pregnancies. A Cochrane review found that planned hospital births for low-risk women may lead to more interventions and complications, without clear evidence of improved outcomes compared to planned home births attended by qualified midwives¹.

The UK’s Birthplace Study concluded that for second-time mothers with low-risk pregnancies, home births were associated with fewer medical interventions, such as caesareans or assisted deliveries, and no difference in outcomes for the baby².

When Home Birth May Not Be Advisable

Despite the reassuring data, home birth is not suitable for everyone. NICE guidelines advise against home birth in cases involving:

Previous caesarean section
Multiple pregnancies
Breech presentation
Pre-eclampsia or gestational diabetes
High BMI or abnormal scans³

A tragic case in Greater Manchester in 2024, involving the death of a mother and baby during a home birth, highlighted the importance of robust risk assessment and clear communication. The mother had previously experienced a postpartum haemorrhage and was advised to give birth in hospital, but opted for home due to feeling unsupported during her first hospital birth. The inquest revealed that risks had not been adequately explained, underscoring the need for informed decision-making.

Midwife-Led Safety and Emergency Preparedness

Qualified midwives attending home births carry essential medical equipment and are trained to manage emergencies such as postpartum haemorrhage and neonatal resuscitation. Transfers to hospital do occur—most often for non-urgent reasons like prolonged labour or requests for stronger pain relief.

According to NICE:

32% of transfers are due to slow labour progress
5% of transfers are due to requests for epidural

The average transfer time from home to hospital is around 49 minutes, with urgent transfers typically faster. Studies show that outcomes are not significantly worse than for those already in hospital.

Systemic Challenges and Access Inequality

Despite the evidence, home birth services in the UK are increasingly restricted. A 2025 report by Birthrights found that 66% of NHS Trusts had suspended or limited home birth services in the previous year. These restrictions disproportionately affect marginalised communities and contribute to trauma and distrust in the maternity system.

Footnotes

Olsen, O. & Clausen, J.A. (2023). Planned hospital birth compared with planned home birth for pregnant women at low risk of complications. Cochrane Library.
NICE Guideline NG235. Intrapartum care. Updated June 2025.
Birthrights. Access Denied: Restrictions to Home Birth in the UK. April 2025.