In the realm of mental capacity, an essential concept that often requires careful consideration is the ‘fluctuating capacity’ of individuals to manage their financial affairs. This term refers to a situation where an individual’s ability to make informed decisions varies over time, which can have significant legal and personal implications.

What is Fluctuating Capacity?

Fluctuating capacity occurs when an individual experiences changes in their mental state, which can affect their decision-making abilities. This may be due to various medical conditions, such as dementia, Alzheimer’s disease, mental health issues, or the effects of medication. It can also vary because of added stress or for a temporary reason, like an infection. Unlike a consistent incapacity, where an individual’s ability to make decisions remains stable over time, fluctuating capacity can vary from day to day or even within the same day.

Legal Implications

From a legal standpoint, determining the capacity of an individual to manage their finances is crucial, especially when making wills, entering contracts, dealing with financial matters or managing estate planning. It is also necessary where the individual has appointed an attorney to make decisions for them, for the attorney to take steps to consider whether the donor of that power can make the decision for themselves.   Only if they cannot make that decision, should attorneys make a best interest decision for them. 

The law requires that individuals must have the necessary mental capacity at the time of making financial decisions or executing legal documents. This poses a challenge in cases of fluctuating capacity, as their ability to understand and consent can change.

To address this, legal professionals and family members must ensure that decisions are made during periods of capacity, when the individual has a clear understanding of the choices available (including making no choice at all) and the implications of their decisions. This may require assessments from medical professionals to confirm that the individual has capacity at the relevant time.

Assessing Capacity

Assessing someone’s capacity when it fluctuates requires careful and often repeated evaluations.  For difficult, complex, or important decisions, these assessments should ideally be conducted by healthcare professionals who can provide an objective view of the individual’s mental state over time. Legal professionals may need to rely on these assessments to ascertain the best times for decision-making and document execution.

Practical Steps for Managing Fluctuating Capacity

Regular Assessments: Regular monitoring of the individual’s capacity by medical professionals can help in planning when to make significant financial decisions or legal agreements.

Legal Advice: Consulting with solicitors who specialize in mental capacity law can ensure that all legal documents are executed during periods of capacity and are thus legally binding.

Supportive Decision-Making: Implementing supportive decision-making frameworks can help individuals with fluctuating capacity by involving them in decisions to the greatest extent possible during their lucid intervals.

Documentation: Keeping detailed records of the individual’s condition at the time of decision-making can be crucial in defending the validity of the decisions in the future.

Conclusion

Fluctuating capacity presents unique challenges in managing financial affairs, particularly in the context of legal validity and personal autonomy. By understanding and planning for these fluctuations, solicitors, healthcare professionals, and families can better protect the interests and rights of individuals with fluctuating capacity.

You can also complete an online enquiry form. One of the Wollens team will contact you as soon as they are available.