Employee, worker or self-employed? Getting employment status right matters because it determines which employment rights someone receives.

Employees have the widest range of rights, including protection against unfair dismissal and the right to a redundancy payment. “Workers” have fewer rights but still benefit from important protections including the National Minimum Wage and paid holiday. Genuinely self-employed people generally fall outside the employment rights framework.

The difficulty is that working out which category someone falls into is not always easy.

Why does substitution matter?

At the moment, someone must normally be required to carry out the work personally to qualify as either an employee or a worker.

This means that substitution can be important. If someone has a genuine and unrestricted right to send somebody else to do the work in their place, that can point strongly towards them being self-employed rather than a worker.

The Government is concerned that this can sometimes produce the wrong result. Someone might be closely controlled by the organisation they work for, for example, but still miss out on worker rights because they have a genuine right to provide a substitute.

It is therefore consulting on whether “significant direction or control” should become another way of establishing worker status. In practice, this would mean looking more closely at how much control an organisation has over the individual, rather than allowing a right of substitution to determine the issue.

And this may only be the beginning…

The Government is also considering introducing a presumption that someone is a worker when they bring certain employment tribunal claims. It would then be for the organisation engaging them to show that they are not.

Looking further ahead, the Government’s ambition is more significant still. It ultimately wants to replace the current employee and worker categories with a single status of “worker”, with everyone within that category potentially receiving full employment rights.

For now, nothing has changed and the existing three categories remain in place. HR teams do not need to start rewriting consultancy agreements just yet. But organisations which regularly use contractors, freelancers or gig workers should keep a close eye on developments. Changes to the test could mean that more people qualify for employment rights in future.

The Government’s consultation closes on 8 January 2027.

About Jon Dunkley

Jon Dunkley is a Partner at Wollens and heads up the firm’s Regulatory Department. Based at our North Devon office, Jon is a highly experienced solicitor with a broad commercial and regulatory practice, supporting businesses, professionals and senior employees across a wide range of legal issues.

If you would like to discuss your situation or find out how we can help, contact our Employment Law solicitors today for expert advice and support.

Speak to Jon Dunkley

Jon is a Partner at Wollens and can advise you. Contact Jon via email jon.dunkley@wollens.co.uk or call 01271 341021.

Jon Dunkley - Wollens Solicitors Devon

You can also complete an online enquiry form. One of the Wollens team will contact you as soon as they are available.

Related News & Insights

2 minute read
When your star performer is causing problems - Wollens Solicitors Devon

When your star performer is causing problems

Read Article
2 minute read
Mitigation of loss: who has to prove what? - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Mitigation of loss: who has to prove what?

Read Article
2 minute read
Harassment: five questions HR should ask - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Harassment: five questions HR should ask

Read Article
3 minute read
Pregnancy and family leave: new dismissal protection from October 2027 - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Pregnancy and family leave: new dismissal protection from October 2027

Read Article
3 minute read
Fire and rehire: which contractual changes will get special protection? - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Fire and rehire: which contractual changes will get special protection?

Read Article
3 minute read
Whistleblowing law: is it time for a rethink? - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Whistleblowing law: is it time for a rethink?

Read Article
3 minute read
Are non-compete clauses on borrowed time? - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Are non-compete clauses on borrowed time?

Read Article
3 minute read
Fire and rehire: a very different world from March 2027 - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Fire and rehire: a very different world from March 2027

Read Article