When does an inappropriate comment at work cross the line into unlawful harassment? A recent EAT decision provides a useful reminder that the answer is not simply whether the employee was offended.

In McManus v British Airways, a cabin crew member with anxiety and depression was told during an occupational health assessment that Access to Work was “not for people like you, it’s for people in wheelchairs”.

She felt harassed by the comment, but her Equality Act harassment claim ultimately failed.

So, when HR is faced with a harassment complaint, what should it be asking?

  1. Was the conduct unwanted?

There must first be unwanted conduct. This can include words, actions, jokes, images or other behaviour.

  1. Was it related to a protected characteristic?

For most Equality Act harassment claims, there must be a connection between the conduct and a relevant protected characteristic. In McManus, the comment related to disability.

  1. What was the purpose or effect?

The conduct must have the purpose or effect of violating the employee’s dignity or creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment.

  1. How did the employee perceive it?

If relying on the effect of the conduct, the employee must actually have experienced the prohibited effect. Their perception therefore matters.

  1. Was it reasonable for the conduct to have that effect?

This is the important final check. HR should consider all the circumstances, not simply whether somebody was upset or offended.

McManus confirms that those circumstances can include the employee’s mental ill health. However, this does not mean that their perception automatically becomes objectively reasonable.

The HR takeaway? Harassment is highly context specific. Investigations should look beyond the words used and consider the employee, the circumstances and the context before reaching conclusions.

About Jon Dunkley

Jon Dunkley is a Partner at Wollens and heads up the firm’s Regulatory Department. Based at our North Devon office, Jon is a highly experienced solicitor with a broad commercial and regulatory practice, supporting businesses, professionals and senior employees across a wide range of legal issues.

If you would like to discuss your situation or find out how we can help, contact our Employment Law solicitors today for expert advice and support.

Speak to Jon Dunkley

Jon is a Partner at Wollens and can advise you. Contact Jon via email jon.dunkley@wollens.co.uk or call 01271 341021.

Jon Dunkley - Wollens Solicitors Devon

You can also complete an online enquiry form. One of the Wollens team will contact you as soon as they are available.

Related News & Insights

2 minute read
When your star performer is causing problems - Wollens Solicitors Devon

When your star performer is causing problems

Read Article
2 minute read
Mitigation of loss: who has to prove what? - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Mitigation of loss: who has to prove what?

Read Article
3 minute read
Employment status: is the worker test about to change? - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Employment status: is the worker test about to change?

Read Article
3 minute read
Pregnancy and family leave: new dismissal protection from October 2027 - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Pregnancy and family leave: new dismissal protection from October 2027

Read Article
3 minute read
Fire and rehire: which contractual changes will get special protection? - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Fire and rehire: which contractual changes will get special protection?

Read Article
3 minute read
Whistleblowing law: is it time for a rethink? - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Whistleblowing law: is it time for a rethink?

Read Article
3 minute read
Are non-compete clauses on borrowed time? - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Are non-compete clauses on borrowed time?

Read Article
3 minute read
Fire and rehire: a very different world from March 2027 - Wollens Solicitors Devon

Fire and rehire: a very different world from March 2027

Read Article